IPE-TM-700 Metallurgy
IPE-TM-700-02
1. Table of Contents 1
2. Purpose 2
3. General 2
4. Accountability 2
5. Procedure 2
6. Materials Selection - General 5
6.1 Design Life 5
6.5 Factors Determining Material Selection 5
7. Environmental Considerations 7
7.1 Resistance to Hydrogen Degradation at Operating Temperatures Below 400°F (204°C) 7
7.2 Resistance to Hydrogen Attack at Design Temperatures Above 400°F (204°C) 7
7.3 Resistance to Sulfur 8
7.4 Resistance to Hydrogen Sulfide at Elevated Temperatures 8
7.5 Resistance to Elevated Temperature Oxidation 8
7.6 Resistance to Acids 9
7.7 Postweld Heat Treatment (PWHT) 9
7.8 Radiographic Examination (RT) 10
8. Special Requirements 11
8.1 Mesh Blankets 11
8.2 Valve Trim 11
9. Low Temperature Requirements 12
10. Process Unit Materials of Construction 13
10.1 Piping Materials of Construction 13
10.2 Materials of Construction Other than Carbon Steel for Common Process Units 13
Attachment 1 Average Rate Curves for High Temperature Sulfur Corrosion 20
Attachment 2 – Figure 1 Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates of 0-5% Chromium Alloy Steel in H2S 21
(Predominantly Hydrogen + Hydrocarbon) Environments at Elevated Temperatures 21
Attachment 2 – Figure 2 Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates of 9% Chromium Alloy Steel in H2S (Predominantly Hydrogen + Hydrocarbon) Environments at Elevated Temperatures 22
Attachment 2 – Figure 3 Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates of 11-13% Chromium Alloy Steel in H2S (Predominantly Hydrogen + Hydrocarbon) Environments at Elevated Temperatures 23
Attachment 2 – Figure 4 Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates of 18% Cr - 8% Ni Alloy Steel in H2S (Predominantly Hydrogen + Hydrocarbon) Environments at Elevated Temperatures 24
Attachment 3 Scaling Rate of Some Alloys in Air versus Temperature 25
Attachment 4 Caustic Soda Service Chart 26
Attachment 5 Piping Material Selection Logic 27
This procedure outlines guidelines for materials selection and sets out special requirements deemed necessary to provide satisfactory service life based on process and metallurgical requirements.
Materials and special requirements shown on the project specifications will govern if there is a conflict with any Inflection Point Engineering Standard Specification.
The Design Engineer is accountable for consulting with both the Process Specialist for a specific process and the Metallurgical Specialist to ensure that this procedure is followed.
The Metallurgical Specialist and the Process Specialist shall review the Customer metallurgical requirements to determine acceptability.
5.1 A Material Selection Diagram (MSD) is required for all Inflection Point Engineering projects, including Revamps where appropriate. A file of “typical” MSDs is maintained within the appropriate Center. These typical MSDs are the accountability of the appropriate Center Leader. Typical MSDs may be used as modules to produce a project specific MSD.
5.2 Work is scheduled between the Project Engineer and the MSD scheduler as far in advance as practicable.
5.3 The Design Engineer will transmit to the Metallurgical Specialist an MSD, which defines and communicates all details of process streams, trace contaminants and alternate operations. The following information must be provided on the MSD:
a. Maximum operating temperatures
b. Equipment design pressures and temperatures including minimum design metal temperature
c. Design H2 partial pressure (Design Pressure x mole fraction H2 in vapor phase)
d. Mole percent H2S in total stream
e. Weight percent or weight ppm S in liquid phase
f. Wet H2S service per NACE MR0103 (Y or N must be indicated for all streams and each piece of equipment – including both shell and tubesides of exchangers). If no equipment is in wet H2S service, apply the following note: “No piping or equipment meets the NACE MR0103 definition of wet H2S service.”
g. CO2 and water partial pressures and dewpoints where applicable (e.g. Selexol, Ecofining, Amine Treating, FCC, etc.)
h. Caustic concentration where applicable
i. For Hydrotreating, Unionfining and Unicracking:
j. For Crude and Vacuum units:
k. List type and concentrations of any acids used or produced in the process.
l. Amine type and concentration for absorbers and strippers; amine solution loading (mol acid gas/mol amine) for lean and rich solutions
m. For heat exchangers identify all exchangers where the tubes are strength welded to the tube sheet
n. For heat exchangers with multiple exchanger shells (e.g. combined feed exchangers), itemize each exchanger with the information required in 5.3.a-m using the (G:\ESE\Skill Centers\MMESC\Technical\Project Skills & Infrastructure Team\Metallurgy\Metallurgy\ExchangerWorksheet.xls).
o. For process water streams
p. The following information shall be provided with the MSD:
5.4 When alternate conditions exist for a unit/piece of equipment, such as regeneration, hydrogen stripping, etc., itemize the conditions (5.3.a-m) for each affected piece of equipment in a separate equipment box.
5.5 For REVAMPS: all piping and equipment shall be included on the MSD with all applicable information from 5.3.a-m. Equipment shall have one of three designations labeled at the top of the equipment box:
(1) Existing – for old equipment that is unaffected by new design conditions.
(2) Revamp – for old equipment that is affected by the new design conditions.
(3) New – for new equipment.
5.6 The Heater Specialist shall select the metallurgy for fired heaters. This information is obtained by the Design Engineer and indicated on the MSD.
5.7 Metallurgy for pressure vessels, heat exchangers and piping is selected per IPE-TM-700-02 and indicated on the MSD by the Metallurgical Specialist.
5.8 After the Metallurgical Specialist has completed the MSD mark-up, the MSD is scanned and a link is sent to the Project Engineer, who forwards it to drafting. Drafting then produces the completed MSD. For additional details, see 2069-03, “Material Selection Diagram (MSD) Work Process.“
5.9 After drafting, it is the accountability of the Design Engineer to compare the drafted copy with the marked-up copy and ensure that they match.
5.10 The Design Engineer informs all interested parties of the metallurgy requirements shown on the MSD.
5.11 The Design Engineer is accountable for revising the MSD if any changes are made to conditions outlined in 5.3 a-p. Submit any such changes to the Metallurgical Specialist for re-review.
5.12 The marked-up MSD originals will be filed and maintained by the Metallurgical Specialist.
Select equipment construction materials to provide a satisfactory service life for the particular environment encountered, such as:
Since there are many factors that contribute to the service life of equipment, these target design lives are based on expected operating conditions. In most cases, standard corrosion allowances will provide a service life in excess of these listed.
6.2 Unless requested otherwise by the customer, specify materials by their generic names (e.g. KCS, Type 304, Monel, etc.).
6.3 Where carbon steel is the required material, specify killed carbon steel. Exceptions are tower trays and heat exchanger baffles, where carbon steel is specified.
6.4 Materials conforming to foreign standards equivalent to the ASTM or ASME Specifications are acceptable. Equivalent foreign materials specifications are those that conform to method of manufacture, chemistry, mechanical properties, quality, testing and inspection.
Materials used to contain process fluids shall have adequate strength at design conditions.
Materials shall possess sufficient resistance to corrosion or hydrogen attack from the process environment including start-up, shutdown and regeneration.
Materials shall possess toughness to resist brittle fracture.
Materials must be reasonably resistant to thermal shock caused by rapid process temperature changes.
In some processes, select materials to provide abrasion resistance from solids in the process stream.
Materials shall possess oxidation resistance if high temperatures in an oxidizing environment are encountered.
Materials shall be compatible with all required fabrication procedures.
Materials of construction must comply with code requirements for design, fabrication, inspection and testing. The following are utilized in the :
Specify killed carbon steel for all equipment and piping, except for tower trays and heat exchanger baffles.
Resistance to hydrogen attack must be provided for materials, in contact with liquids and vapor containing hydrogen, at elevated temperatures and pressures. Use the latest edition of API Publication 941, Steels for Hydrogen Service at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures in Petroleum Refineries and Petrochemical Plants”, as a guide for selecting hydrogen resistant materials. Use the following method to utilize this API curve:
a. Determine the hydrogen partial pressure (psia) by multiplying the mole fraction hydrogen in the vapor phase by the absolute DESIGN PRESSURE.
b. The hydrogen partial pressure in a liquid is the same as in the vapor in equilibrium with it. Do not use the mole fraction hydrogen in the liquid for determination of the hydrogen partial pressure. An example where this controls material selection is a Unicracking separator liquid pump and its associated piping.
c. Using the DESIGN TEMPERATURE for the particular equipment, find the point defined by it and the DESIGN HYDROGEN PARTIAL PRESSURE (determined above).
d. The point defined above identifies the minimum metallurgy to resist hydrogen attack. If this point is on a material line, specify the next higher material.
Resistance to elevated temperature sulfur must be provided for materials in contact with sulfur bearing hydrocarbon streams. Determine the corrosion rates in these streams using the graph in Attachment 1, Average Rate Curves for High Temperature Sulfur Corrosion. These curves aid in determining corrosion rates for materials in contact with sulfur bearing hydrocarbon streams and are used primarily for crude, vacuum, visbreaker, asphalt oxidizing units, and raw oil charge lines to hydrotreating, Unionfining and Unicracking units.
In using this curve, use the maximum OPERATING TEMPERATURE of the equipment and select the corresponding corrosion rate for one of the materials listed. Adjust the corrosion rate with a correction factor, taking into account the weight percent sulfur. Note that the reference sulfur level for this curve is 1.0 weight percent.
For determining materials of construction for process streams handling hydrogen sulfide (H2S) and hydrogen at elevated temperatures, use the curves in Attachment 2, “Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates”, for steels in H2/H2S environments at elevated temperatures. This includes a family of curves grouped according to alloy content as follows:
| Figure 1 0 – 5% Chromium | Figure 2 9% Chromium | Figure 3 11 – 13% Chromium | Figure 4 18% Cr-8% Ni Stainless Steel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbon Steel | 9 Cr - 1 Mo | Type 405 | Type 304 |
| C- 1/2 Mo | Type 410 | Type 304L | |
| 1 Cr - 1/2 Mo | Type 410S | Type 304H | |
| 1 1/4 Cr - 1/2 Mo | Type 316 | ||
| 2 1/4 Cr - 1 Mo | Type 316L | ||
| 3 Cr - 1 Mo | Type 316H | ||
| 5 Cr - 1/2 Mo | Type 321 | ||
| Type 321H | |||
| Type 347 | |||
| Type 347H |
In utilizing these curves, use the maximum anticipated OPERATING TEMPERATURE during normal operation and volume percent H2S to determine an anticipated corrosion rate for a particular material.
For determining an anticipated metal loss from oxidation, use Attachment 3, Scaling Rates of Some Alloys in Air Versus Temperature. The temperature used is the maximum anticipated OPERATING TEMPERATURE for sustained operation.
Typically, specify Monel where resistance to HCl (formed during processing) must be provided. Some examples of this are Monel lining in the top of a crude column, Monel mesh blankets in Platforming equipment, and Monel trim valves in streams handling wet Platformer gas.
Where resistance to naphthenic acids is required, use Type 317L.
Typically, use Type 317L in Crude and Vacuum Units processing crude oils that possess total acid numbers (TAN, mg KOH/g Crude) over 0.6, or in areas of high velocity where temperatures range from about 450F (232C) to 750F (399C). The most common areas where Type 317L is employed for naphthenic acid protection is the vacuum column lining from the 450F (232C) zone and hotter, the heavy vacuum gas oil circuit, and the vacuum unit heater coils and transfer piping.
Typically, use Type 317L in units downstream of the Crude and Vacuum Units that possess total acid numbers (TAN, mg KOH/g oil sample) over 1.5, in areas where temperatures range from about 450F (232C) to 750F (399C)
Where resistance to phosphoric acid is required, use Type 316L. Examples of this are in certain areas of catalytic condensation units where phosphoric acid “syrup” is formed.
For resistance to hot HF acid environments and HF acid concentrations below about 60 percent at ambient temperature, use Monel 400. Some examples of this (all in the HF Alkylation Process) are the Acid Regenerator, Polymer Surge Drum and the scrubbing section of the Relief Gas Scrubber.
Specify post weld heat treatment for killed carbon steel regardless of Code requirements under the following environmental conditions:
Where the stream meets the definition of wet H2S service as defined by NACE MR0103, paragraph 1.3.5.1.
For equipment where the process stream contains any amount of HF acid. (This is not a requirement where seal or strength welding of heat exchanger tubes is performed.)
Reference Attachment 4, “Caustic Soda Service Chart", to determine if PWHT is required. Use maximum operating temperature and concentration of NaOH (weight percent). Follow the same criteria for KOH. PWHT all equipment and piping in caustic service subject to steamout.
In MEA, DEA or other amines at a concentration greater than 2.0 wt %.
RT examination is required for process reasons in addition to construction code requirement in hydrofluoric acid environments:
a. 100 percent radiographic examination is required for the following equipment, due to the high concentration of HF acid. See Inflection Point Engineering Standard Specification 3-11 for additional details.
| Acid Mixer | Dump Drum |
|---|---|
| Acid Settler | HF Stripper |
| Acid Storage Drum | HF Stripper Feed Settler |
| Acid Regenerator | Isostripper |
| Alkylation Reactor | Isostripper Sidecut Receiver |
| Depropanizer | Liquid Knockout Drum |
| Depropanizer Feed Settler | Polymer Surge Drum |
| Depropanizer Receiver |
b. Spot radiographic examination is required for all vessels (excluding those listed above) containing any amount of acid.
c. 100% RT is required for 1 Cr – ½ Mo, 1¼ Cr – ½ Mo, 2¼ Cr – 1 Mo and 3 Cr – 1 Mo. See Inflection Point Engineering Standard Specification 3-12 for additional details.
The standard construction material for vessel mesh blankets is an 18% Cr - 8% Ni stainless steel, usually Type 304. The grid and wire are constructed of the same material as the blanket. Exceptions to the standard material are:
Examples are the top mesh blanket in a vacuum column, product separator mesh blanket in Butamer, Isomar, Penex and Platforming Units and mesh blankets in compressor suction drums handling chloride containing gases.
Mesh blankets in contact with hydrocarbons or gas streams containing HF.
An example is the product separator in Unicracking service.
Examples are in Catalytic condensation units where the presence of phosphoric acid syrup is anticipated.
The standard material for valve trim in a killed carbon steel valve is a hardened straight chromium stainless steel, usually 11-13% chromium. Exceptions to the standard valve trim are:
c. Use 300 series stainless steels (Types 304 or 316) for valve trim for all carbon steel valves handling hot carbonate solutions in the CO2 removal section of a hydrogen production unit.
9.1 At an MDMT below -20°F (-29°C), killed carbon steel must meet the requirements of ASME Section VIII, Part UCS-66.
9.2 At an MDMT below -55F (-46C), use nickel alloy steels containing 3 1/2% Ni, or austenitic stainless steel; e.g. Type 304.
Attachment 5, "Piping Materials Selection Logistics", provides a step-by-step approach for selecting piping materials of construction and corrosion allowances. This approach considers resistance to hydrogen, combined sulfur and hydrogen sulfide.
Use the same approach for materials selection as in crude units; however, do not use Monel in the upper section of the vacuum tower.
When naphthenic acids are a consideration, use Type 317L for the heater coils, heater transfer piping, vacuum column lining (the bottom section up to and including the zone where the temperature is approximately 450F (232°C)), and the heavy vacuum gas oil circuit.
(1) Use the same approach for materials selection as crude units.
(11) For valve trim materials, see section 8.2.
(2) Specify Type 316L for the following equipment:
(a) Line the effluent rectifier in the bottom area up to the feed point.
(b) Acid knockout drum
(c) Piping from the reactor effluent pressure control valve to the rectifier, and from the effluent rectifier to the acid knockout drum.
(1) Contact Condenser Design
(2) Overhead Receiver Design
Reference Sulfur Level – 1.0 wt%)
| Correction Factor | Correction Factor |
|---|---|
| Wt% | % of Base Rate |
| <0.02 | 0% |
| 0.02 | 5% |
| 0.03 | 10% |
| 0.06 | 20% |
| 0.1 | 30% |
| 0.2 | 48% |
| 0.3 | 60% |
| 0.4 | 67% |
| 0.5 | 75% |
| 0.6 | 80% |
| 0.7 | 85% |
| 0.8 | 90% |
| 0.9 | 95% |
| 1 | 100% |
| 1.2 | 109% |
| 1.4 | 115% |
| 1.5 | 120% |
| >1.50 | 120% |
1. Select hydrogen resistant material - use DESIGN temperature and DESIGN hydrogen partial pressure to consult the API Publication 941 Chart. This is the minimum required metallurgy.
2. Using MAXIMUM OPERATING temperature and weight percent sulfur, determine corrosion rate on material selected from the "Average Rate Curves for High Temperature Sulfur Corrosion".
3. Using MAXIMUM OPERATING temperature and volume percent H2S, determine corrosion rate from "Trend Curves for Predicting Corrosion Rates" of 0-5 % Chromium Alloy Steel in H2S Environments at Elevated Temperatures."
4. Compare corrosion rates anticipated from both weight percent sulfur and volume percent H2S.
5. Using the higher of the two rates, choose a metallurgy and corrosion allowance such that the designated design life is met or exceeded.
6. Corrosion allowances for various alloys can be found in Inflection Point Engineering Specification 8-1200.
© 2026 Inflection Point Engineering, LLC. All rights reserved. The content of this page — including calculation methods, reference data, written analysis, interactive tools, and source code — is the intellectual property of Inflection Point Engineering, LLC and is protected under applicable copyright, trademark, and trade secret laws. Unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, modification, or derivative use in whole or in part is prohibited without prior written consent.
Disclaimer. This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute professional engineering advice. Calculations, reference data, and methodologies are based on published standards and accepted engineering practice but are not a substitute for engineering judgment, site-specific analysis, or review by a licensed Professional Engineer. Inflection Point Engineering, LLC makes no warranties, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, completeness, or fitness for a particular purpose of any content presented here, and shall not be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages arising from its use. Users assume all risk associated with applying this content to real-world design, operations, or decisions.
© 2026 Inflection Point Engineering, LLC. All rights reserved.