Inflection Point Engineering Section 15 — Inspection

Principles and Practices for Inspection and Testing of In-Plant Refinery Equipment

IPE Engineering Practice IPE-EP-15-4-1

Document number: IPE-EP-15-4-1 · Section: 15 — Inspection

SCOPE

2.0 REFERENCES

The latest edition of the following standards and publications are referred to herein.

STANDARDS AND PUBLICATIONS

IPE Engineering Practices
EP 1–1–2 Revisions/Additions/Deletions to IPE Engineering Practices EP 1–1–3 Deviations to IPE Engineering Practices
EP 7–3–1 Rerating of Pressure Vessels
EP 15–3–1 Training, Qualifying and Certifying Personnel for Inspection and Testing of Plant Equipment
EP 15–4–2 In–Plant Inspection of Existing Piping Systems EP 15–4–3 In–Plant Inspection of Existing Pressure Vessels EP 15–4–4 In–Plant Inspection of Existing Tankage
EP 15–4–6 In–Plant Inspection of Existing Fired Heaters EP 15–4–8 In–Plant Inspection of Existing Stacks
EP 15–4–9 In–Plant Inspection of Pressure Relief Valves
API
Std. 510 Pressure Vessel Inspection Code Std. 570 Piping Inspection Code
Std. 653 Tank Inspection, Repair, Alteration, and Reconstruction
ASME Codes
Sec I Power Boilers
Sec VIII Pressure Vessels, Division 1

STANDARDS AND PUBLICATIONS (Cont.)

National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors
NB–23 National Board Inspection Code
Code of Federal Regulations
29 CFR 1910.119 Process Safety Management of Highly Hazardous Chemicals

3.0

3.1

3.2

3.3

3.4

3.5

3.6

3.7

3.8

3.9

3.10

DEFINITIONS

Equipment – Static pressure containing equipment within a plant where scheduled inspection and/or testing is required by either company requirements, jurisdictional regulations or industry codes to assure personnel safety, environmental compliance and reliable operations.

Inspection – The examination or examination and physical testing or checking of functional operation.

Inspection Activity – Any of a number of inspection techniques that can be used to evaluate equipment conditions. These include, but are not limited to, visual inspection, any of the routine or specialized NDE methods used in equipment integrity evaluation, field or laboratory metallography, use of corrosion coupons and probes, hardness testing, and mechanical testing of trepan samples.

Inspection Authority – Person(s) competent in the assessment of plant equipment for continued safe operation. The Inspection Authority shall have such experience and expertise as is necessary to clearly identify potential failure mechanisms and define appropriate inspection plants and procedures to ensure failure mechanisms are clearly identified and monitored.

Inspection Grade – A grading of equipment on a scale 0, 1, 2 or 3, to indicate the maximum interval between thorough inspections.

Inspection Plans – A listing of all the inspection activities together with their due dates and intervals that occur within a complete inspection cycle for each equipment item. An inspection cycle will begin with and end with a thorough inspection. The extent of the inspections to be performed under the inspection plan will be defined in the refinery’s inspection procedures as amended by the recommendations from the last inspection.

Management – The person or persons legally responsible for a Plant owned or operated by

IPE Engineering Company. Owner – Inflection Point Engineering, LLC.

Plant Inspector (Plant Integrity Assessor) – The person or persons appointed by management to be responsible to the Static Equipment Inspection Authority for the inspection of equipment within the plant.

Registration – The act of assigning a unique identification number and an individual record file for each item of critical equipment.

GENERAL PRINCIPLES

All equipment requiring inspection and/or testing shall be identified and registered before being placed into service. The inventory shall include all such items in each plant and there shall be a procedure for updating this inventory when equipment is added, modified, withdrawn from service, or when new inspection requirements are identified.

Personnel responsible for inspecting equipment must be qualified and trained, as defined in EP 15–3–1 and have such practical and theoretical knowledge and actual experience of the type of equipment to enable them to carry out the examination, and render sound technical judgement.

All the inspections shall be formally reported (see paragraph 8.4 of this Practice) and the reports placed in the record file. Management must be alerted to any significant events or changes that may affect the safety or operational efficiency of the equipment, and the need for significant repairs or renewals.

To maintain a consistently high operational standard, inspection functions shall be subject, at intervals no greater than 5 years, to an audit by a team external to the plant appointed by management, so that the management may be assured that inspection responsibilities are being carried out satisfactorily. This team shall provide management with a formal report of the results and any recommendations.

REGISTRATION

All equipment requiring periodic inspection within the scope of this Practice shall be identified by a distinct and unique identification number. With the exception of piping systems, the identification number shall be stamped or otherwise clearly marked on the equipment.

Where it is proposed to transfer equipment to a different duty the inspection grading must be reviewed. Where a change of operating conditions is proposed, including changes in design throughput, careful consideration must be given to the possible effects on the equipment and the inspection grading confirmed or modified.

Any proposed modification or repairs to plant or equipment must be subject to a formal system of approval in which the design, fabrication, inspection and test requirements are considered by appropriate specialists. The static equipment Inspection Authority will ensure that the modifications and repairs are carried out in accordance with the required procedure and that complete documentation of all technical details is retained in the records system.

FREQUENCY AND EXTENT OF INSPECTION

The intervals which elapse between inspections may be dictated by industry codes, such as API 510, API 570, or API 653 and federal requirements, such as OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119; and/or jurisdictional regulations. In any case, the following shall apply in such a way as to supplement but not interfere or overrule the governing inspection interval requirements.

Equipment shall be subject to scheduled periodic inspection and shall be given an Inspection Grade (0, 1, 2 or 3) that indicates the maximum interval that may elapse between thorough inspections (See 6.3, 6.5 and Table 1 and Table 2 ).

Where process equipment has such design maturity that its operating conditions and rate of deterioration can be predicted with confidence, an Inspection Grade may be based on the service history of identical items. All documentation relating to the above assessment must be recorded and on–stream monitoring carried out to confirm the basis of the assessment.

6.8.4 Piping Systems

The principles of grading may not apply to all critical piping systems. For most piping, sophisticated corrosion monitoring programs will effectively and conservatively determine inspection intervals and predict retirement dates. A thorough, integrated program for piping inspection will include on–stream/off–stream wall thickness measurements to monitor internal corrosion and periodic visual examinations to monitor external deterioration. Complete guidelines for piping inspections are included in EP 15–4–2.

6.9 Assigning Inspection Classes

6.9.1 Thorough inspection of pressure vessels and piping shall be performed to the extent necessary to assure the equipment is adequately sound for the intended service. The equipment shall be assigned a classification number 1, 2, or 3, or 4 based on the consequence of failure of the equipment.

Other equipment may require additional procedures in order to comply with good engineering practice but the principles included in the above documents should be used as a guide.

7.0

7.1

7.1.1

7.1.2

7.2

7.3

7.3.1

7.3.2

7.4

INSPECTION ORGANIZATION

General

It has been the usual practice for the Owner to employ its own staff for the inspection of equipment. In some cases, for shutdowns or to satisfy statutory requirements, contract Plant Inspectors are used. Also, certain specialist technical inspection services may be employed (particularly in the field of non–destructive testing, to assess the condition of equipment).

The work of all these non–staff inspection services must be coordinated by the static equipment Inspection Authority who shall have the final responsibility for evaluating the results of the data collected, advising management of the condition of the equipment and ensuring that applicable legislation is observed.

Management Delegation of Authority

Management of each plant shall assign the responsibility, and delegate the authority, for the correct application of this Practice to those persons or departments most appropriate and with the necessary technical abilities and qualifications. This delegation shall be in writing.

Organizational Structure

Management of each plant is responsible for ensuring that the static equipment Inspection Authority at the plant is given terms of reference defining the activities for which it is responsible.

The static equipment Inspection Authority shall have direct access to management for those occasions when it is not possible to reach an agreement acceptable to all the functional groups, or for those occasions when the static equipment Inspection Authority deems it necessary to acquaint management directly with information of considerable importance affecting the safety of personnel or equipment.

Basic Responsibilities of the Static Equipment Inspection Authority

The basic responsibilities of an static equipment Inspection Authority shall be:

INSPECTION REPORTS AND RECORDS

All such requirements must be strictly observed. All applicable statutory requirements for documentation must be strictly observed.

9.0 TABLES

TABLE 1

INSPECTION INTERVALS FOR EQUIPMENT AND INSTALLATIONS

(Excluding storage tanks)

Maximum interval between Thorough Inspections(1) (months) Maximum interval between Thorough Inspections(1) (months) Maximum interval between Thorough Inspections(1) (months) Maximum interval between Thorough Inspections(1) (months)
No. Plant or Equipment Reference Grade
0
Grade
1
Grade
2
Grade
3
1 Pressure vessels, including heat exchangers EP 15–4–3 24 48 96 120
2 Spheres and Bullets EP 15–4–3 48 72 96 120
3 Non–pressure vessels 60 72 96 120
4 Direct Fired Boilers (2) EP 15–4–5 24 72 96 120
5 Fired heaters EP 15–4–6 24 48 60 72
6 Pressure–relieving devices EP 15–4–9 24 48 96(3) 120(3)
7 Stacks and chimneys EP 15–4–8 24 48 96 120
8 Steel structures –– –– 60 120

NOTES:

TABLE 2

INSPECTION INTERVALS FOR ABOVE GROUND STORAGE TANKS(1)

TYPE OF INSPECTION TYPE OF INSPECTION TYPE OF INSPECTION TYPE OF INSPECTION TYPE OF INSPECTION TYPE OF INSPECTION
EXTERNAL EXTERNAL EXTERNAL EXTERNAL EXTERNAL INTERNAL(6)
In–Service Survey Roof Survey(2) Floating Roof Seal(3) Visual(4) UT Shell Thickness
Measurements
(5)
Monthly Annually Annually/ 5 Years 5 Years 5/15 Years 10/20 Years

NOTES:

Remaining Corrosion Allowance (in.)  0.25 Corrosion Rate (inches/year)

or 15 years, whichever is less

The Maximum interval shall not exceed 20 years. When the floor plate corrosion rate is unknown, and similar service experience is not available to determine it, the floor plate thickness shall be measured within the next 10 years of tank operation in order to establish a corrosion rate for determining future inspection intervals.

See API 653 P2.4.7 for detail methods for calculating the minimum floor plate thickness.

TABLE 3 SAMPLE LIMITS

Number of Items in Group 2 to 4 5 to 8 9 to 12 12 to 40 Over 40
Minimum number of items in sample 1 2 3 4 10%